Elicit

I  am trying out a new product called Elicit to write this post. It is a blog client by Bingo Bango Software. WordPress 1.5.x does not offer me a WYSIWYG interface or spell checking and so I find it quite an annoyance to write and edit my posts solely online.

I’ve tried other similar programs such as BlogJetRocketPost and Qumana. BlogJet inserted way to much markup into my posts, making it tough to edit them once they were in WordPress. RocketPost never actually connected to my blog. Qumana did not seem to offer a way to post something as a “draft”, which is important if you start to write, are running out the door, and then want to save it to WordPress for future publishing.

As a result, I have been using w.bloggar for some time but it does not give me a real-time WYSIWYG (you have to switch over to the “preview” tab) and also has a pretty poor dictionary for spell checking. I haven’t been thrilled by it but it is free and the best blog client I’ve found to date.

Elicit has much more to offer than other blog client software. With built in doclets that let you search Technorati, Flickr, and del.icio.us tags, you don’t have to leave the application to do your research - and that’s nice. Unfortunately, I think it fails at some of the basics.

  1. It’s not intuitive to create a new post. In order to do so, you have to double click in the Schedule area.
  2. In the Entry Editor, there are all sorts of buttons except the essentials - buttons to insert links, images, etc. You have to access these functions via menu options.
  3. No “more” tag support. When pulling up an old post that had the “more” tag in it, Elicit did not recognize the additional text.
  4. My WordPress categories were not pulled in, so I could not assign them and had to select them in WordPress itself.
  5. There seems to be a snag while writing a post where some of my words would come out liket his while I wast yping (those examplesa ctully ocurred without me trying to explictily show them - I obviously edited all the other times it happened).
  6. Spell checker only indicates there is a mispelling, it does not fix the error.
  7. Similar to BlogJet, Elicit puts all mark-up elements into the post (p tags, ‘ ’, etc.), making it nearly impossible to read and edit once it is pushed up to WordPress.
  8. The install required additional software support - Microsoft Visual J#. If I wasn’t so interested in finding a better blog client, I would have cancelled it then and there.

Elicit has some potential but I am sticking with w.bloggar for now. Hopefully, at some point, someone or some company will get this right. I’ve read that Flock offers a cool WYSIWYG editor and drag-and-drop blogging tools - maybe that will be my answer (but no invite love!). If not, I will gladly pay for the software that offers a comprehensive and bug-free solution.

1 Trackbacks/Pings Trackback

  1. [...] A majority of my blogging efforts over the past two months have been dedicated to Web 2.0. I’ve interviewed people like Greg Linden of Findory and Peter Cooper of FeedDigest. I’ve reviewed products like Elicit and analyzed how to build a better web based feed aggregator. I’ve boldly proclaimed that Google search is so Web 1.0 and that approaches like Wink and BlinkList will more closely resemble Search 2.0. I’ve even held my first blogoposium, dedicated to helping the non-technical community understand Web 2.0 concepts. I’ve also consulted to several Web 2.0 companies over the past two months (and at no cost), providing valuable feedback for feature improvements, identifying bugs and errors, and the like. [...]

10 Comments On This Post

  1. Priyantha says:
    October 7, 2005 at 8:17 am

    Hi,
    Have your tried Zoundry Blog Writer? (www.zoundry.com) It is still in beta, so lacks a few features (e.g. spellcheck - in works) in the current beta release, but supports most of other features such as DnD, FTP, post as draft, multiple blogs, tagging etc. The WP api of it, strips out new lines (since WP stores content as a simple string data) - so, you might find it a bit difficult to edit a post via WP UI. (new lines are maintained for a MT 3.x server and LiveJournal). Give it a try. Btw, I am from Zoundry.

  2. QiSoftware says:
    October 7, 2005 at 9:36 am

    I am interested in all types of blogging tools and add-ons. Thanks for the review [Elicit].

    Q…

  3. Tris Hussey says:
    October 7, 2005 at 10:59 am

    Good review of Elicit. We’re working on publish properties for future versions and will have a new version released next week.

    Instead of draft, what you can do with Qumana is save to HTML and re-open later.

  4. Blaine says:
    October 7, 2005 at 1:21 pm

    Sorry to hear about your problems. We are just a week old :) and unfortunately our WP support has some holes.

    If you have it in you, we will have 1.1.2 that fixes most of the known issues you mentioned available next monday 10/10.

    Thanks for giving our product a try (thanks for the great suggestions) and hopefully you will come back.

  5. Ken Yarmosh says:
    October 7, 2005 at 1:38 pm

    Thanks everyone for your responses…I appreciate the updates and am happy to try out new or updated products. It’s important for me to find a product I am comfortable with, because whatever I use, I recommend to my clients.

  6. Manish says:
    October 7, 2005 at 3:35 pm

    In RocketPost, choose Setup Wizard from the Tools menu. That should get you up and running in under 2 minutes.

    If not, let me know what URL you use to log into your blog, and I’ll tell you what to enter into the wizard to try RocketPost. It’s got pretty good WordPress support.

    Feel free to email me.

  7. Angel says:
    October 8, 2005 at 2:15 am

    Have you tried Ecto? Their webpage is http://ecto.kung-foo.tv/

    I just purchased the software this weekend after using it for the full trial period and am using it on my Wordpress and Typepad blogs. I highly recommend them….they make versions for the Mac and PC.

  8. Ken Yarmosh says:
    October 8, 2005 at 2:44 am

    I’ve not tried Ecto yet. Thanks for the tip!

  9. Manish says:
    October 27, 2005 at 4:34 pm

    We just released a $37 version of RocketPost:

    http://www.anconia.com/rocketpost/pricing.asp

  10. bingo game play says:
    February 13, 2006 at 5:37 pm

    thanks for the tips am interested in learning all about blogging tools and add ons and will check out ecto.many thanks

Voice your opinion